Robert Coverdale's Struggle — A Reader’s Guide
Edition facts
For Robert Coverdale's Struggle — A Reader’s Guide, the stored edition analysis reports 69,834 words, 5 hr 4 min estimated reading time, and 36 detected text sections.
The text analysis averages about 12.4 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “New England -- History -- 19th century -- Fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
ut furnished in the plainest and scantiest style. The entire furniture of the house would not have brought twenty-five dollars at auction, yet for twenty-five years it had been the home of John and Jane Trafton and for twelve years of their nephew, Robert.
My readers will naturally ask if the fisherman had no children of his own. There was a son who, if living, would be twenty-three years old, but years before he had left home, and whether Ben Trafton was living or dead, who could tell? Nothing had been heard of him for five years.
Mrs. Trafton’s affections had only Robert for their object, and to her sister’s son she was warmly attached--nearly as much so as if he had been her own son.
Her husband’s love of drink had gradually alienated her from him, and she leaned upon Robert, who was always ready to serve her with boyish devotion and to protect her, if need be, from the threats of her husband, made surly by drink.
Many days she would have gone to bed supperless but for Robert. He would push out to sea in his uncle’s boat, catch a supply of fish, selling a part if he could or trade a portion for groceries. Indeed he did more for the support of the family than John Trafton did himself.
“It’s about time for supper, Robert,” said his aunt; “but I’ve only got a little boiled fish to offer you.”
“Fish is good for the brains. Aunt Jane,” said Robert, smiling.
“Well, I suppose it’s no use waiting for your uncle. If he’s at the tavern, he will stay there until he is full of liquor and then he will reel home. Come in and sit down to the table.”
Robert entered the cabin and sat down at a side table. His aunt brought him a plate of boiled fish and a potato.
“I found just one potato in the cupboard, Robert,” she said.
“Then eat it yourself, aunt. Don’t give it to me.”
“No, Robert; I’ve got a little toast for myself. There was a slice of bread too dry to eat as it was, so I toasted it and soaked it in hot water. That suits me better than the potato.”
“Haven’t you any tea, aunt--for yourself, I mean?” Robert added quickly. “I don’t care for it, but I know you do.”
“I wish I had some. Tea always goes to the right spot,” said Mrs. Trafton; “but I couldn’t find a single leaf.”
“What a pity!” said Robert regretfully.
“Yes,” sighed Mrs. Trafton; “we have to do without almost everything. It might be so different if Mr. Trafton wouldn’t drink.”
“Did he always drink?”
“He’s drank, more or less, for ten years, but the habit seems to have grown upon him. Till five years ago two-thirds of his earnings came to me to spend for the house, but now I don’t average a dollar a week.”
“It’s too bad, Aunt Jane!” said Robert energetically.
“So it is, but it does no good to say so. It won’t mend matters.”
“I wish I was a man.”
“I am glad you are not, Robert.”
“Why are you glad that I am a boy?” asked Robert in surprise.
“Because when you are a man you won’t stay here. You will go out into the world to better yourself, and I shan’t blame you. Then I shall be left alone with your uncle, and Heaven only knows how I shall get along. I shall starve very likely.”
Robert pushed back his chair from the table and looked straight at his aunt.
“Do you think, Aunt Jane,” he demanded indignantly, “that I will desert you and leave you to shift for yourself?”
“I said, Robert, that I shouldn’t blame you if you did. There isn’t much to stay here for.”
“I am sorry you have such a poor opinion of me, Aunt Jane,” said the boy gravely. “I am not quite so selfish as all that. I certainly should like to go out into the world, but I won’t go unless I can leave you comfortable.”
“I should miss you, Robert, I can’t tell how much, but I don’t want to tie you down here when you can do better. There isn’t much for me to live for--I’m an old woman already--but better times may be in store for you.”
“You are not an old woman, Aunt Jane. You are not more than fifty.”
“I am just fifty, Robert, but I feel sometimes as if I were seventy.”
The novel opens with a precise domestic tableau: Robert Coverdale, a fifteen-year-old boy in a calico shirt and patched trousers, is asked by his aunt whether he has seen his uncle. The uncle is at the tavern, drinking away his earnings. This early scene establishes a pattern of contrast—between the boy's resolution never to drink rum and his uncle's dissipation, between the aunt's despondency and Robert's emphatic nod. Alger's narrator directly addresses the reader, defending the choice of a ragged hero by listing his 'energy, talent, honesty and a resolute will.' The cabin on the cliff, with its fine sea view but furniture worth less than twenty-five dollars, becomes a symbol of precarious respectability.
Clothes as a Marker of Worth
Robert's clothing is a recurring point of tension. In the first chapter, the narrator anticipates that well-dressed city boys might 'turn up their noses' at his ragged appearance. When Robert arrives in Boston, two boys laugh at his outlandish clothes, but he responds with good humor rather than shame. He acknowledges his clothes are 'of strange cut' and asks for help finding a store. The scene in the clothing shop sharpens the pattern: a clerk dismisses Robert as a 'scarecrow' and assumes he wants a job, not to buy. Robert's cool retort—'Are you the owner of this shop?'—shifts the power dynamic. The clerk's rudeness is rebuked by a portly gentleman, and Robert is treated as a customer. Alger uses the clothing transaction to dramatize how a poor boy can command respect through self-possession and direct speech.
Direct Address and the Reader's Role
Alger's narrator repeatedly breaks the fourth wall, shaping how the reader should judge the hero. In the opening, the narrator says 'My readers will naturally ask if the fisherman had no children of his own,' then answers. Later, when describing Robert's poverty, the narrator insists that a boy with 'energy, talent, honesty and a resolute will' cannot be considered poor. This rhetorical strategy positions the reader as a potential skeptic who must be won over. The narrator also uses direct address to contrast city and country readers, assuming a city audience that might look down on a country boy. These interjections create a collaborative tone: the reader is invited to see past appearances and root for Robert's manly traits. The effect is to make the moral lesson explicit without relying on plot alone.
The Threat of Dispossession
From the first chapter, the Coverdale household is under financial pressure. The uncle drinks up his earnings, leaving little for the family. The cabin's furniture would not fetch twenty-five dollars at auction. Later, a mortgage looms: a Mr. Jones complacently reflects that in four weeks he will turn Robert and his aunt 'out of doors.' This threat of homelessness is the engine of the struggle. The excerpts do not reveal whether Robert succeeds in raising the money, but the pattern is clear: the boy must navigate a world where adults are either weak (the uncle) or predatory (Mr. Jones, the rude clerk). Alger frames the conflict not as a single villain but as a series of tests—of honesty, temper, and resourcefulness—that Robert must pass to preserve his home.
Readers familiar with Alger's formula will recognize the setup: a virtuous boy, a threatened home, and a journey to the city. But the excerpts reward attention to small details—the calico shirt, the aunt's sewing, the clerk's sneer—that ground the moral drama in material reality. Notice how often Robert's voice carries the scene: his directness disarms mockery and exposes pretension. The novel's tension lies not in whether Robert will succeed, but in how his character will be tested by each new encounter.
Reading about Robert Coverdale’s quiet endurance in that fishing village, I found myself thinking of another sort of struggle. That old copy of Robert Coverdale's Struggle felt so small against the moral weight of revolutionary France, yet both share that ache of personal duty. Later, the memory drifted to The Gods are Athirst — Background and Themes. Odd, how one book’s shadow simply lingers into another’s light.
There are no reviews for this eBook.
Before you leave, reflect on the book
Use these questions to collect your thoughts before moving on.