For the Master's Sake: A Story of the Days of Queen Mary — A Closer Reading

(0 User reviews) 301

In Category - Historical Psychological Social Fiction

Authors: Holt, Emily Sarah, 1836-1893, Petherick, Horace, 1839-1919 [Illustrator] Digital Source: Project Gutenberg Gutenberg Release Year: 2008 First Publication Year: Not confirmed

Key Word: Historical fiction; England -- Social life and customs -- 16th century -- Fiction; Counter-Reformation -- England -- Fiction Target Reader: Readers of public-domain and historical texts

Book Edition: Project Gutenberg digital edition Book Language: en

Edition facts

Words 26,473

Reading time 116 min

Text sections 3

Before opening For the Master's Sake: A Story of the Days of Queen Mary — A Closer Reading, the edition data offers a quick orientation: 26,473 words, 1 hr 56 min estimated reading time, and 3 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 18.2 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Historical fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Source: Project Gutenberg record #24105

In Mary Tudor's England, a young woman named Agnes Stone faces domestic tyranny and religious questioning. Through dialogues with Friar John Laurence, the novel explores Protestant-Catholic tensions, personal conscience, and the cost of discipleship, using period-authentic speech and domestic settings.

Editorial Edition Score 4.5/5

★★★★★ ★★★★★

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated

Description quality20 pts
Title & short description10 pts
Source metadata20 pts
Text length15 pts
Chapters / structure15 pts
EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

File: pg24105

Read the Text

Sempringham had his town house in Cow Lane; and the Earl of Bath lived on the further side of the Fleet River, with Furnival's Inn beyond, the residence of the Barons Furnival, now merged in the Earldom of Shrewsbury. Mistress Winter lived in the last house at the north end of the lane, next to Cow Cross, and almost in the country. There is no need to name her neighbours, with two exceptions, since these only are concerned in the story. But in Cow Lane every body knew every body else's business; and the mistress at the Fetterlock could not put on a new ribbon without the chambermaid at the Black Lion being aware of it. Do not rush to the conclusion, gentle modern reader, that Cow Lane was full of inns or public-houses. Streets were not numbered in those days; and in order to effect the necessary distinction between one house and another, every man hung out his sign, selecting a silent woman [Note 1], a blue cow, a griffin, or a rose, according as his fancy led him. Sign-painting must have been a profitable trade at that time, and a very necessary one, when scarcely one man in twenty knew his alphabet; and the cardinal figures were cabalistic signs to common eyes.

The two families previously alluded to lived at the southern end of Cow Lane, and their respective names were Flint and Marvell. Mistress Flint was a cheerful, good-tempered woman, with whom life went easily, and who had a large family of sons and daughters, the youngest but one, little Will, being a special favourite with Agnes. The Marvells were very quiet people, who kept their opinions and feelings to themselves; though their son Christie, a mischievous lad of some twelve years, was renowned in Cow Lane for the exact opposite.

The day was drawing towards evening, when Agnes, as she turned round from emptying a pail of dirty water into the common sewer of Cow Lane, detected the burly figure of Father Dan, the Cordelier Friar, who was Mistress Winter's family confessor, coming up from Seacoal Lane. Not without some fears of his errand, she waited till he came near, and then humbly louted--the ancient English reverence, now conventionally supposed to be restricted to charity children.

"Christ save all here!" said the priest, holding up three fingers in the style of benediction peculiar to his Order.

Taking no further notice of Agnes, he marched within, to be cordially welcomed, and his blessing begged, by Mistress Winter and Dorothy; for Joan was gone to see the bear-baiting in Southwark.

Father Dan was a priest of the popular type--florid, fat, and jovial. His penances were light and easy to those who had it in their power to ask him to dinner, or to make gifts to his Order. It might be that they were all the harder to those from whom such favours were not expected.

The Cordelier took his seat at the supper-table just laid by Dorothy, this being an easy and dainty style of work in which that young lady condescended to employ her delicate hands. Mistress Winter was busily occupied with a skillet containing some savoury compound, and the Friar's eyes twinkled with expectant gastronomic delight as he watched the proceedings of his hostess. Supper being at last ready, the three prepared to do justice to it, while Agnes waited upon them. A golden flood of buttered eggs was poured upon the dish in front of the Friar, a cherry pie stood before Dorothy, while Mistress Winter, her sleeves rolled up, and her widow's barb [Note 2] laid aside because of the heat, was energetically attacking some ribs of beef.

"Had Joan no purpose to be back for supper, Doll?" demanded her mother.

"Nay," said Dorothy; "Mall Whitelock bade her to supper in Long Lane. I heard them discoursing of the same."

"And what news abroad, Father?" asked Mistress Winter. "Pray you, give me leave to help you to another shive of the beef. Agnes, thou lither [wicked] jade, whither hast set the mustard?"

Continue Reading →

The novel opens with a torrent of abuse from Mistress Martha Winter, whose scolding of the servant Agnes Stone is rendered in dense, period-inflected prose: 'Good lack, Agnes! ... thou art right well be-called Stone; for there is no more wit nor no more quickness in thee than in a pebble.' The speech, laced with exclamations like 'Bodykins o' me!' and 'Beshrew thee,' immediately establishes a household where authority is exercised through verbal violence and where religious change—'preaching came therein'—is resented as disruptive to domestic order. Agnes, 'pale-faced, trembling,' offers no defense, setting up a dynamic of silent endurance that will be tested by the theological conversations to come.

The Weight of Words: Speech as Power and Resistance

Mistress Winter’s opening monologue is a performance of control: she mocks Agnes’s name, derides her piety as 'idle foolery,' and contrasts her own labor with Agnes’s supposed idleness. The rhythm of her speech—piling up accusations, rhetorical questions, and commands—mirrors the relentless pressure Agnes faces. Later, Dorothy’s 'sugary style' when asking about Friar Laurence reveals a different kind of verbal weapon: feigned sweetness used to mock and pry. Agnes’s replies are 'as short as civility permitted,' a quiet resistance through brevity. The novel thus uses dialogue not only to advance plot but to map social hierarchies: who may speak at length, who must answer briefly, and how tone itself can enforce or subvert power.

Theological Debate in Domestic Space

The excerpted theological exchange between Agnes and Friar Laurence takes place not in a church but in an ordinary setting, after he has been observed at the Cross. Their dialogue is structured as a Socratic catechism: 'What! not Saint Mary?' 'Certes, nay, Father, as methinks.' Laurence leads Agnes to question the necessity of Mary as intercessor by using an analogy about a child in trouble—'should he need for to run home and fetch his mother to entreat thee?'—which she immediately understands. The argument is precise: God’s justice and mercy are both perfect, Christ is the sole Advocate, and 'of an advocate with the Son never a word saith He.' The scene shows how Reformation ideas could be introduced through patient, logical questioning within everyday encounters, and how a young woman’s 'unwisdom' becomes the ground for serious theological reflection.

Silence and the Unspoken: What Agnes Does Not Say

Agnes’s characteristic response to accusation is silence: 'she made no attempt at self-defence.' When asked whom she loves, she hesitates, thinking it 'something new and strange to think that she could love, or could be loved, since the death of her mother.' The narrative gives us her inner state—fear, meekness, a sense of isolation—but leaves much unspoken. Her questions to Friar Laurence are framed with deference: 'I pray you pardon me if I speak foolishly.' Yet she persists, asking 'how then needeth a mediator at all?' This tension between outward submission and inward searching is a recurring pattern. The excerpts do not reveal whether Agnes will act on her growing convictions, but they establish that her journey is as much about finding a voice as about finding truth.

Readers should attend to the interplay between the historical setting—the reign of Mary Tudor, with its religious persecution—and the intimate scale of the story. The novel’s preface warns that 'the battle of the Reformation will soon have to be fought over again,' suggesting that the domestic conflicts mirror larger struggles. Notice how everyday objects (pans, beads, chicks) and routines (feeding chickens, hearing mass) are woven into theological argument. The authenticity of the period language rewards slow reading, and the silences of Agnes may speak as loudly as the sermons she hears.

I keep thinking about Agnes, how her quiet questions cost her so much—and yet she stayed gentle. It reminded me of a book I once loved, The Boy Scouts of Bob's Hill A Sequel to 'The Bob's Hill Braves' — A Reader’s Guide, where courage shows up small, in ordinary afternoons. Both left a warmth I didn’t expect, like a light left on in a room I’d already left.